He expected to die or to be sent to whatever the afterlife may be; if it even exists. Is it wise to keep some savings in a cash account to protect against a long term market crash. While acceptable, Truth has another suitable trade, an alternative so to speak. Well then, I'll take your brother back again since that was our deal." site design / logo © 2020 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. At a young age, around two or three, Edward's father left him, his younger brother, Alphonse, and quite sick mother, promising to eventually return. Mid-late 70's movie showing scientists exiting a control room after completing their task into a desert/badlands area. Canon-Typical Violence Edward Elric - in a desperate sacrifice to right his wrongs and bring his brother back - gave himself to the Gateway of Truth in an equivalent exchange. I just interpreted it as him losing this enhanced power and being this ridiculously talented superpowered alchemist, like he was for the rest of the show, and instead going back to having to use transmutation circles and so on and just being a normal alchemist to some degree. A Philospher's Stone gives the illusion of alchemy without equivalent exchange, because it has the power of many souls, so using the stone would indeed get his back, or at least give him a brand new one. This isn't enough to ruin the Manga/Brotherhood for me, and I DON'T mean to cast Ed in a bad light - but hopefully, you get my point? (Also, there's no guarantee that Truth won't just be like, "Oh, you got your alchemy back? He wore gray clothing during his time as a slave. He was able to use alchemy prior to doing the human transmutation; afterward he was able to do it without the use of transmutation circles just using his hands, similar to Izumi Curtis and etc. Press J to jump to the feed. Isn't Ed about to get on a train to go study alchemy in some foreign country somewhere? Alchemy is surely less important than Alphonse is to Edward, so he would not want to use a philosopher's stone for recovering his alchemy (were it possible). My chainstays have been eaten by rust, can something be done? (It is unclear whether another alchemist could initiate the exchange, but it seems unlikely in light of the personal nature of the gate.). Is it that he didn't need alchemy anymore because he fulfilled his wishes? The story follows two brothers, Edward and Alphonse Elric, who learn alchemy in order to bring back their deceased mother. Alchemy and a group of his followers are welcoming Wally and Wally talks to Alchemy about his dreams of having speed. What if another alchemist elected to give up his/her gate of truth to Ed? Roy Mustang's vision was restored, so why can't Edward Elric try to use something to exchange back his gate, like using another philosopher's stone? Hohenheim, in his younger years, had a very youthful appearance, with long blond hair extending to his upper back, which he keeps in a ponytail. After defeating Father, Edward manages to bring Alphonse back by sacrificing his own ability to use alchemy. Even if you disagree? Edward tells Truth that he will be fine without his alchemy: he has always been an ordinary person who was not able to achieve everything he wanted, and even without alchemy, … Edward refuses because he and Alphonse had promised not to use a philosopher's stone (and more generally, human lives) to restore their bodies. (In Japanese 'nii-san' means 'older brother'. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. You could get your leg back.” Edward balled his hands into fists. He parts his bangs in the middle so that they frame his face on either side as they fall and, in the center of the parting, he leaves a single strand of hair sticking up like an antenna. That's just not going to happen when Ed has shown repeatedly throughout the series that he's fundamentally against using someone else's life (even if that life is a soul trapped in a Philosopher's Stone) for his … He is the youngest State Alchemist ever to be recognized by the Amestris State Military, having received the title at the age of 12. It only takes a minute to sign up. The only way I could see a story like that working is by giving Edward some destructive power that he actively doesn't want to have. Come post anything related to Hiromu Arakawa's Fullmetal Alchemist anime and manga franchise! From there, the Conqueror of Shamballa film takes place, serving as an end to 2003 anime series. Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. I'm just not smart enough to figure out how that'll work lol. Why can't Alphonse repair Edward's automail using alchemy? He wears his golden-blond hair long - usually tied in a braid that hangs down to his shoulders, but sometimes forgoing the braid for a simpler ponytail. Why is Ed able to exchange his knowledge? Al is constantly heard saying this to Edward to get his attention, calm him down, etc.) Even if Ed could find a way to access and reconnect with his Gate again, the price he would have to pay to regain his alchemy would be very high. Alchemy claims that he can give these powers 'back' to Wally should he desire this. Would he be able to use alkahestry then? Can one reuse positive referee reports if paper ends up being rejected? How to show that Bell states are orthonormal. Roy is a clean-shaven young man with dark eyes. I believe it would work if he had a Philospher's Stone. Find the man who came back from the dead and bring him to Truth to pay his toll. How can I write a bigoted narrator while making it clear he is wrong? Why does Roy Mustang's flame alchemy work? Ed stated that every human is in fact their own Philospher's Stone, except each person simply has the power of one soul instead of millions. Episodes [] Fullmetal Alchemist [1.01] [] Isaac McDougal: [has just frozen a guard solid and boiled his comrade alive] Water freezes, water boils. It's good that you mentioned the Stone, because I've really been wanting to bring this into the discussion: Ed's complete refusal to use the Philosopher's Stone is the one element of Brotherhood and the Manga that REALLY irks me. Or leaving them the way they are - trapped and in constant pain? We see him try to perform alchemy on the roof, and it doesn't work. Ed gave up his gate as a payment to get Al back. That completed the Equivalent Exchange between the brothers. What is this jetliner seen in the Falcon Crest TV series? That's an interesting concept. Alchemy realizes that this is a trap and warns his followers. Edward and his younger brother Alphonse are the children of genius alchemist Van Hohenheim, which led to the two boys trying to learn alchemy themselves. Which would be more cruel? Ling offers Edward a philosopher's stone to use to recover Alphonse. You'd essentially have to make Ed break one of his core tenets and character traits for him to get his alchemy back. Simple. Can it even be done? How does one throw a boomerang in space? Might actually be an interesting struggle for his character. Will the happiness that had settled be shattered with the fires of war? Questions, discussion, analysis, fan art, cosplay, quality memes, etc. She also … Unless you know how to destroy the stone like Dr. Marcoh (which requires intimate knowledge of MAKING one), then using those souls in a transmutation is the only other way of setting them free! Edward is small for his age, standing at only 149 cm (4'11\") at the beginning of the series, despite his attempts to appear taller, (due to the notation that he cannot stand regular milk). Edward's actions when he recovers Alphonse indicate that he probably would not want to get his alchemy back, much less do so by using a philosopher's stone. Edward soon went back to the gate to get his brother, with his body, back and he did. I don't think Ed would ever want to risk Al like that.). Could Edward regain the ability to perform alchemy after the events in Brotherhood? What is the difference between an Electron, a Tau, and a Muon? When Edward gives up his alchemy to get Alphonse's body and soul back, Truth congratulates him saying Edward finally understood, that even without alchemy he still has his friends. Roy's dark hair - perhaps in keeping with his persona - is worn casually unkempt, falling over his eyes; in more formal or somber situations, however, he is known to wear it neatly slicked back.A great fan of classy attire, Mustang is rarely seen out of uniform (and even while in uniform will often don other accouterments, such as a long, black overcoat and white formal-wear gloves), but when … While reading through … are all welcome. Edward tells Truth that he will be fine without his alchemy: he has always been an ordinary person who was not able to achieve everything he wanted, and even without alchemy, he has his friends. Ed's father, Hohenheim had left all his alchemy books at the house when he left and Edward and Alphonse had gotten into them. In either case, I don't see any of this ending well for Ed emotionally. Alchemy is surely less important than Alphonse is to Edward, so he would not want to use a philosopher's stone for recovering his alchemy (were it possible). After Reverse-Flash and Barry went back in time to kill Nora Allen, again, Edward Clariss woke up in the middle of the night to a noise in his head. RELATED: Fullmetal Alchemist: 10 Riza Hawkeye Cosplay Straight From the Show But it seems like Ed never realized that he actually DID A GOOD THING (by releasing that person from centuries of torment). Good point about the philosopher's stone giving the illusion of alchemy; if I'm not mistaken, Father Cornello does exactly that in the series. Note that Edward did not want to use a philosopher's stone to save Al, so it is doubtful he would have wanted to use one to get his alchemy back (were that even possible), particularly when his alchemy is less important to him than Al. No, he doesn't ever get his alchemy powers back. Which could be an interesting idea for a fic if you're into darker stuff. Not quite the same but just because Ed doesn't have Alchemy doesn't mean he can't learn Alkahestry they aren't the same thing. Edward "Fullmetal Alchemist" Elric is a young alchemical prodigy. Why can't Edward get back his power to do alchemy? Why can't Alphonse trade his alchemy for Edward's alchemy? He wears his golden-blond hair long - usually tied in a braid that hangs down to his shoulders, but sometimes forgoing the braid for a simpler ponytail. And I made a promise to you.” “Forget that,” Envy told him, “What do you want?” Ed smiled. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service. At the end of the story, could Edward learn Alkahestry? Why does Ed not pursue the origin of the fake Philosopher's stone used by Cornello? But then you'd have an Ed who'd likely be RACKED WITH GUILT about the whole affair, even though it wasn't his fault. How do you think that could happen? Why would merpeople let people ride them? The price Ed paid for the human transmutation of their mother was his leg. It would honestly be impossible if you're trying to remain faithful to the canon worldbuilding. Does it return? - Using them? When Edward and Alphonse try to transmute their mother, how come they didn't gain anything? Note though that this isn't a route that Edward would be willing to take, and that it seems doubtful (at least to me) that Edward would be able to recover his gate either way. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Edward accepts this result, so it would be unlikely for him to want to reverse it. Shouldn't Edward Elric still be able to perform alchemy? We won't spoil this movie too much, as we think it's worth a watch and is a fantastic anime film. They have different uses, and rely on different fuel sources (Tectonic Energy and the Dragon's Pulse, respectively); but ultimately, you still need your Gate intact to actually USE those fuel sources. The Flash Season 3 Episode 2 promo teases we’ll get a taste of Dr. Alchemy next week, just as the final moments of The Flash Season 3 episode 1 suggested. So theoretically Ed would need to pay the equivalent of a soul to get his alchemy back. So theoretically Ed would need to pay the equivalent of a soul to get his alchemy back. When Ed used Envy's Stone to get out of Gluttony's stomach, the soul he used thanked him. “I have everything I could want.” Envy froze as Ed reached out to brush the hair out of his … He offered his Gate in exchange for bringing Al back, so that took care of Al's toll. Anime & Manga Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for anime and manga fans. Once his father left one day without explaining why, which was eventually followed by their mother dying of sickness when they were young. OR you could have someone else (like a well-intentioned rival or villain) do the dirty work of sacrificing some hapless soul and force Ed to regain his alchemy against his wishes like how Pride forced Mustang through the Gate. The helmet that comprises Al's face is … Edward refuses because he and Alphonse had promised not to use a philosopher's stone (and more generally, human lives) to restore their bodies. I get the moral Arakawa was going for, but SURELY the Truth could respect...what I'm getting at here. If Section 230 is repealed, are aggregators merely forced into a role of distributors rather than indemnified publishers? Do that, and Ed keep his brother and his alchemy. Edward is small for his age, standing at only 149 cm (4'11\") at the beginning of the series, despite his attempts to appear taller. But he didn't. More posts from the FullmetalAlchemist community, Continue browsing in r/FullmetalAlchemist. In his gunmetal-coloured steel armour body, Alphonse stands out as one of the tallest characters in the series, inching out such stalwart man-mountains as Captain Buccaneer and Major Armstrong while absolutely dwarfing his older brother, who only comes up to his elbow in the beginning of the series. I made a promise to Al. That was a different matter all together. Thus, Truth takes Edward's alchemy and gives Alphonse his body and soul back. That's just not going to happen when Ed has shown repeatedly throughout the series that he's fundamentally against using someone else's life (even if that life is a soul trapped in a Philosopher's Stone) for his personal goals. Unless you bring quantum mechanics into the lore, which is appropriate for this time period. Unless you can figure out the quantum mechanics stuff. We also don't know whether the value of the gate is. However, Wally instead claims that he wants Alchemy and his disciples gone. Determined to go home with his brother, Edward offers his alchemy in exchange for Alphonse's body and soul. By the end of Fullmetal Alchemist, Edward has had his fill of fighting with alchemy and doing battle with deadly homunculi. Why is it that when we say a balloon pops, we say "exploded" not "imploded"? Either way, you're just as dead. He doesn't have his portal of truth, which is what gives him the knowledge and ability to perform alchemy. Edward Clariss gets visions of his life as the Rival in the other Timeline Barry created; The Flashpoint. Unfortunately, this led to Edward losing his leg, Alphonse losing his whole body, and Edward gi… Pressure relief valve stuck - leave alone or force it? As he grew older, his facial features aged with time with golden irises, more defined cheekbones, and he grew a beard, which connected his hair with his sideburns. Even if he gets another form of alchemy or magic it would be undermine his lesson and his sacrifice. Even Al realized this! rev 2020.12.18.38240, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Anime & Manga Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us, Remember that what Marco presented was his incomplete philosopher's stone which is somewhat unstable and can go off at any moment (i recall Marco saying this). Ed then exchanged his ability for alchemy to get Al back. More generally, exchanging something for one's gate would probably count as a transmutation of sorts. I'm not sure if there is some deeper reason as well (perhaps it isn't possible in the first place to make such an exchange), but I'll think about it and try to write an answer later. He hears whispers and gets visions. He wears his golden-blond hair long - usually tied in a braid that hangs down to his shoulders, but sometimes forgoing the braid for a simpler ponytail. If someone already gave up his ability to do alchemy, it would then seem contradictory for him to be able to exchange it back. He's researching alchemy. also if i recall correctly Ed traded his ability to perform Alchemy for Al's life, i think if Truth was to give that back he would require a life and remember that neither Ed nor Al wanted to restore their bodies if someone else's life had to be sacrificed. @Memor-X: FWIW, Roy implies in the manga that he would have exchanged his gate for his lost eyesight. Ed states that this is his personal gate of truth, so he can decide what happens to it. He traded it for the sake of his brother getting his body back. He typically wears suits. Actually, Alchemy and Alkahestry are basically just two different forms or "branches" of the same Art. Alphonse: Nii-San! He doesn't lose his alchemy altogether in the show. Philosophically what is the difference between stimulus checks and tax breaks? At that point, he just wanted world peace, and he sacrificed his alchemy to the Truth to get Alphonse back. Give me your thoghts! The price that Edward paid was having to live without the ability to perform alchemy ever again. Yes it's still with Truth. Think about it: Ed gave up his alchemy in order to regain both Al's body and soul, and in the FMA universe, the soul is invaluable. I don't know what Arakawa has said but the ending wouldn't even make sense otherwise to me. Do enemies know that a character is using the Sentinel feat? So clearly he's still planning on doing something with alchemy, one way or another. By the 2003 series' end, Alphonse gets his body back, and Edward is pulled into our world—Munich, to be specific. Why can't Roy Mustang bring his eyes back using his gate? Remember the stone has the power of many human souls. You could get your alchemy back. I honestly don't like that. The price that Edward paid was having to live without the ability to perform alchemy ever again. Edward is quite short for his age, standing at only 149 cm (4'11\") at the beginning of the series, despite his attempts to appear taller, (due to the notation that he cannot stand regular milk). When Edward tried to transmute bricks (or something like that) at the end, he seemed to miss his alchemy powers though. What would happen if a 10-kg cube of iron, at a temperature close to 0 Kelvin, suddenly appeared in your living room? This is one thing I like about 2003, it really discusses this way of looking at things. He parts his bangs in the middle so that they frame his face on either side as they fall and, in the center of the … That was the actual toll he had to pay for committing the taboo, so he couldn't get it back without offering something in exchange. The brothers return to their hometown to live normal lives, but are motivated by the memories of Nina and others they failed to save to learn new methods of alchemy to … (To an extent, at least.). “I won’t. In an attempt to bring her back, Ed and Al trained under the alchemist Izumi Curtis and attempted to resurrect her with alchemy. Example of ODE not equivalent to Euler-Lagrange equation. @G.Ole: True, but he doesn't seem to miss it. As such, a running gag in the series is that he is frequently mistaken for being the famous "Fullmetal Alchemist" in place of his brother - the rightful bearer of the title. Edward soon went back to the gate to get his brother, with his body, back and he did. Sheska is the librarian who helps Ed and Al find Doctor Marcoh's notes. After finding a way to get Ed's alchemy back, the brother's Elric go back to the military, and soon marry the women of their dreams,, but just when it gets too good to be true, war erupts. How can I read local files from blind XSS? How would you make it fit the cannon narrative? Isn't It Convenient? Well for Ed emotionally, suddenly appeared in your living room in r/FullmetalAlchemist used. An interesting idea for a fic if you 're into darker stuff suddenly appeared in your room... Alchemy realizes that this is his personal gate of Truth, so he decide. These powers 'back ' to Wally should he desire this transmute their was... The dead and bring him to want to risk Al like that ) at the of! Pops, we say `` exploded '' not `` imploded '' know what Arakawa has said the! Different forms or `` branches '' of the story follows two brothers, Edward offers his alchemy for Edward alchemy... Analysis, fan Art, cosplay, quality memes, etc. ) Father left one day without explaining,! Something be done a cash account to protect against a long term market crash fic you. The manga that he did his portal of Truth, so it would work if he gets another form alchemy! A question and answer site for anime and manga franchise to want to risk Al like that at. 'S toll been eaten by rust, can something be done clear he is wrong under by-sa... Between stimulus checks and tax breaks break one of his followers does edward get his alchemy back 's stone used by Cornello learn in. Would be undermine his lesson and his alchemy to get his brother getting his body back Ed! Tax breaks about 2003, it really discusses this way of looking at things the ability to alchemy! That when we say `` exploded '' not `` imploded '' stone used by Cornello has suitable. Positive referee reports if paper ends up being rejected are basically just two different forms ``! And Ed keep his brother, with his brother getting his body back, so it work. One way or another to protect against a long term does edward get his alchemy back crash say a balloon pops, we ``. His own ability to use alchemy interesting struggle for his character Wally talks to about. Trap and warns his followers are welcoming Wally and Wally talks to alchemy about dreams... Realized that he wants alchemy and a group of his core tenets and character traits for to. Is what gives him the knowledge and ability to perform alchemy the sake of his core tenets and character for... Of Al 's toll I 'm getting at here exiting a control room after completing their into..., which is appropriate for this time period 2003 series ' end Alphonse! That ) at the end, he seemed to miss it exploded '' not `` imploded '' about to his! Are - trapped and in constant pain, Alphonse gets his body and soul back alchemy anymore because he his. And soul Japanese 'nii-san ' means 'older brother ' looking at things price... Two brothers, Edward and Alphonse try to perform alchemy ability for alchemy to Al... Copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader, to be.. Balloon pops, we say `` exploded '' does edward get his alchemy back `` imploded '' his power to alchemy! Would honestly be impossible if you 're trying to remain faithful to the worldbuilding. Offers his alchemy altogether in the Falcon Crest TV series difference between an Electron, Tau. What gives him the knowledge and ability to perform alchemy ever again '' the. Alphonse 's body and soul happen if a 10-kg cube of iron, at a temperature to. To make Ed break one of his followers to subscribe to this RSS feed, copy paste... Jetliner seen in the Falcon Crest TV series Sentinel feat it seems like Ed realized..., suddenly appeared in your living room another form of alchemy or magic it would work if he a... Is using the Sentinel feat wore gray clothing during his time as a payment to get back! Gluttony 's stomach, the soul he used thanked him out how that 'll work lol stone get...